Stories of Provenance Research: Henry Beddy, Baptist Missionary
On 31 May 1916, the India Office Library purchased seven items at auction from Hodgson & Co. Lot 29 cost £1 10 shillings, with 9d postage. The correspondence about the purchase is significant because it establishes that the items once belonged to the collection of Sir Alexander Johnston, Chief Justice and President in Council in Ceylon (now Sri Lanka). This provenance information had not previously been recorded in our catalogues and the link between the items had been obscured.
Notice of auction at Hodgson & Co - Westminster Gazette 27 May 1916 British Newspaper Archive
Lot 29 included copies of letters relating to Baptist Missionary Henry Beddy. Born in Dublin, he enlisted in the East India Company’s Bengal Army at 19, arriving in India in 1811 to serve in the Bengal Artillery. Beddy married three times. His first wife Mary Anne died in childbirth in 1816, and his second wife (also Mary Anne) died in 1822. On 16 January 1823 he married Margaret MacDonough, and they had at least 11 children.
List of correspondence relating to Henry Beddy -Mss Eur C92
Henry Beddy was baptised into the Baptist faith about 1827, and having left the Bengal Army was appointed as a Baptist Missionary to Patna in 1831. Margaret’s younger sister Ellen (Eleanor) MacDonough lived with the Beddys from childhood and was closely involved in missionary work, running the Orphan Refuge.
Ellen became involved with government servant George Hutteman. Henry Beddy tried to put an end to the relationship, but on 20 November 1847 Ellen eloped with George, married, and moved to Calcutta. Beddy found it impossible to understand Ellen’s actions and wrote a number of letters to her, besmirching her character. On 1 December 1847 he wrote ‘Not a member of my family shall ever speak to you with my permission... I shall impress on the children’s mind that their Aunt Ellen MacDonough is to them dead’. Beddy was later to admit: ‘I had written language capable of being used to my discredit’.
The Huttemans attended the Lall Bazar Baptist Church in Calcutta. The Minister James Thomas wrote to Beddy about his sister-in-law. Beddy’s reply accused Ellen of falsehood and deception and stated that George was an ‘unbeliever’. His hostile attitude led to an investigation into his conduct towards Ellen.
Note by James Thomas introducing the collection of documents about Henry Beddy and Ellen MacDonough -Mss Eur C92
Thomas gathered together copies of correspondence from the various protagonists and witnesses, so they could be presented to a Baptist Committee in London. Beddy’s own letters admitted ‘an intimacy, friendship and affection sprang up between us that led to great familiarity, and it is now lamentably true that this familiarity was looked upon by some persons as improper’, whilst Reverend Nathaniel Brice was of the opinion that ‘there are facts connected with the affair which would make your ears tingle...’.
Extract of letter from Henry Beddy to James Thomas, 13 March 1848 --Mss Eur C92
Removed from Patna, Beddy and his family moved to Simla, where he became Pastor at the First Baptist Church. He died there on 3 June 1857.
Ellen and George had three daughters, and after his death in 1866, she married Reverend John Lawrence of Monghyr. She died in Christchurch, Hampshire, in 1879.
The India Office appreciated that the contents of the volume were problematic. In a letter dated 26 January 1936 the Librarian H N Randle wrote that he hesitated to include the letters as part of the forthcoming catalogue of manuscripts as ‘there may be relatives alive, even after 90 years and it seems best to let these personalities rest in obscurity for another hundred years’.
Provenance research is more than acquiring a greater understanding of our collections and their history. It uncovers fascinating human stories along the way.
Lesley Shapland
Archivist & Provenance Researcher
India Office Records
Further reading:
Mss Eur C92: Volume compiled by Rev J Thomas, Calcutta, containing copies of correspondence relating to charges of misconduct against Rev Henry Beddy, missionary at Patna for the London Baptist Missionary Society
IOR/L/R/7/20, R961/16: India Office Record Department Annual Files, 1916
Mss Eur F303/23, p.137: India Office Library, Day Book, 14 Jul 1916
IOR/L/R/9/26, L36/37: Library Committee Papers & References, 1937
Missionary Herald, May 1832
Full text of 'The story of the Lall Bazar Baptist Church Calcutta : being the history of Carey's church from 24th April 1800 to the present day'
India Office Library Catalogue of Manuscripts in European Languages. Vol. II, Pt. II: Minor Collections and Miscellaneous Manuscripts. By G. R. Kaye and E. H. Johnston. Section I, Nos. 1–538 (London: HMSO, 1937)